Now that I’ve wrapped up my 31 Longreads in 31 Days challenge, here are some thoughts, observations, and takeaways from the experience.
1. Longform nonfiction is alive and well
With the collapse of the magazine industry and the shrinking newspaper business, many have suggested that longform nonfiction feature writing is a dying genre, with business models favoring shorter, “web-friendly” content.
But I kept finding evidence to the contrary. Magazines may be vanishing, but other sources are taking their place. I found excellent longform nonfiction stories at places that didn’t exist a few years ago, such as Buzzfeed, Grantland, and SBNation. Smaller publications like Seattle’s The Stranger and Dallas’ D Magazine had two of the best stories I read.
I wrote up 31 stories, but I read twice that many last month. Some stories were disappointing. Others just didn’t seem a good fit. Some I couldn’t finish. But I never lacked for options. I wound up with dozens of other fine longreads I didn’t get to. I could have I made it 365 longreads in 365 days, and still left plenty unread.
2. There’s no substitute for a great story; but it takes a great writer to tell it well
Some of the pieces I read were clearly driven by an incredible underlying story: the fight for the life of Kelley Benham’s four-month-premature baby; Bill Fong’s shot at perfection; the deadly tornado that ripped through Utica, Illinois. But it took skillful, smart writing to elevate each of these articles into something memorable. Dry news stories could have been written about any of these subjects, but instead, the stories used the power of classic storytelling techniques: scene, character, point of view, and vivid, concrete details to bring each of these narratives to life.
On the other hand…
3. Great nonfiction stories can take something seemingly ordinary and mine it for rich, complex ideas
In contrast to #4… some of the best work I read focused on topics that were relatively mundane, but explored them to reveal depth and meaning. Nick Paumgarten looked at the issue of commuting and explored its cultural, sociological, and personal impact. Eli Saslow’s look at the day in the life of a Virginia pool salesman told a broader story about the struggling American middle class and the ongoing economic recession. Malcolm Gladwell looked at the unlikely success of a pre-teen girls basketball team in California and connected it with broader ideas about underdogs and insurgent campaigns.
The 31 Longreads
- “How to Build An American Car” by Justin Heckert
- The Bravest Woman in Seattle by Eli Sanders
- Urban Meyer Will Be Home for Dinner by Wright Thompson
- Fatal Distraction by Gene Weingarten
- Still Richard by David Davis
- Atari Teenage Riot: The Inside Story Of Pong and the Video Game Industry’s Big Bang by Chris Stokel-walker
- There and Back Again by Nick Paumgarten
- Waiting for Bigfoot by Colleen O’Neil
- Todd Marinovich: The Man Who Never Was by Mike Sager
- A Wicked Wind Takes Aim by Julie Keller
- Walking His Life Away by Gary Smith
- Netherland by Rachel Aviv
- The Secret History of Guns by Adam Winkler
- The Most Amazing Bowling Story Ever by Michael J. Mooney
- Lottery Winner Jack Whittaker’s Losing Ticket by David Samuel
- The Lost City of Z by David Grann
- The Hard Life of an N.F.L. Long Shot by Charles Siebert
- A Eulogy for #Occupy by Quinn Norton
- Never Let Go by Kelley Benham
- Life of a Salesman by Eli Saslow
- A Fighter Abroad by Brian Philips
- Battleground America by Jill Lepore
- Embedded with the Reenactors by Nick Kowalczyk
- A Life After Wide Right by Karl Taro Greenfeld
- The Hacker is Watching by David Kushner
- Looking for Someone by Nick Paumgarten
- How David Beats Goliath by Malcolm Gladwell
- The Trading Desk by Michael Lewis
- Atonement by Dexter Filkins
- The Truck Stop Killer by Vanessa Veselka
- The Loved Ones by Tom Junod
4. It’s the scenes, stupid.
When I look back at all 31 stories, a common element in almost every one was the use of scenes; a dramatic moment (or moments) that revealed a lot about the subjects and themes of the stories and provided the dramatic context for larger ideas and themes. Regardless of the topic or the writing style, great scenes anchored these narratives and elevated them from the page.
5. Reading apps are awesome
If you’re not already using Pocket, Readability, or Instapaper, you should. I used to lug around stacks of articles and magazines in my bookbag; no more. Reading apps make it simple to collect articles to read and sync them across multiple devices, as well as make them easier and more enjoyable to read on small screens. I traveled a lot during December, and being able to keep dozens of stories on-hand without printing anything out was extemely helpful. My only gripe with all of these is that none of them offer a way to annotate stories. I’d love to see that feature in 2013.
While I’m at it, one new tool I’ve started to use is readlists.com: add in a bunch of links to stories you want to read and it will create a single .epub file to read on your kindle, ipad, or mobile phone. For starters, he’re a readlist I’ve created with my 10 favorite longreads from the 31 I read in December. You can grab it can put it on your favorite e-reader or tablet.
6. The New Yorker is still the best starting place to look for longform nonfiction
I found incredible work in GQ, The Atlantic, The New York Times Magazine, and a wide range of smaller publications. But again and again, I kept finding myself digging into longform stories from the New Yorker. As a designer, the magazine kills me; it looks like something for an old granny in Vermont. But week after week it delivers smart, thoughtful features and profiles that run the gamut of longform nonfiction. I can barely keep up with my subscription — I have a pile of unread New Yorkers in my office — but when I can steal the time to dig through them, I am rarely disappointed.
7. Writers whose work I most want to emulate:
Nick Paumgarten. Malcolm Gladwell. Gary Smith. Gene Weingarten.
8. Writers whose work I admire like hell, but could never hope to replicate:
Julie Keller. Mike Sager. Kelley Benham. Tom Junod.
9. The best thing I read in 2012:
Never Let Go. Kelley Benham’s story is moving, thoughtful, beautiful, and extremely well written. Read it.